Traditional Archery Discussions on the Leatherwall


•••Y5 broadhead•••?

Messages posted to thread:
the Black Spot 24-Jan-23
Batman 24-Jan-23
the Black Spot 24-Jan-23
raghorn 24-Jan-23
Bigdog 21 24-Jan-23
raghorn 24-Jan-23
raghorn 24-Jan-23
old fudd 24-Jan-23
the Black Spot 24-Jan-23
smrobertson 25-Jan-23
the Black Spot 30-Jan-23
Corax_latrans 30-Jan-23
the Black Spot 31-Jan-23
the Black Spot 01-Feb-23
raghorn 01-Feb-23
From: the Black Spot
Date: 24-Jan-23




Anyone heard of a MA-3 look-a-like that has “Y5” on them?

From: Batman
Date: 24-Jan-23




New to me. Where did You encounter?

From: the Black Spot
Date: 24-Jan-23

the Black Spot's embedded Photo



Son says they have Y5 on them

From: raghorn
Date: 24-Jan-23




Not MA-3, they are Spiral Killer heads made in Italy. The stamp is YS not Y5. there was a left and right spiral and also a straight blade. The early ones looked kinda crude, later they looked better.

From: Bigdog 21
Date: 24-Jan-23




X2 raghorn. them look more like vintage ones. Newer ones seem to have more twist.

From: raghorn
Date: 24-Jan-23




These look like straight blades. The Spiral Killer actually had a curve like the wave at your favorite surfing spot.

From: raghorn
Date: 24-Jan-23

raghorn's embedded Photo



I found a picture in my old broadhead files.

From: old fudd
Date: 24-Jan-23




I'll stick with the Old MA 3 And MA 3 L Bone Busters>Although the tips look OK

From: the Black Spot
Date: 24-Jan-23




Are they a decent broadhead?

From: smrobertson
Date: 25-Jan-23




Speaking for the MA-3. I know these are a older design and materials, same for the MA- 2. They show up on old arrows at flea markets and yard sales. Don't write these heads off as inferior. And I'm well aware of all the heads out there, new designs and materials, but the MA (Make All Tool & Die) heads sharpen easily (soft steel). I mounted a few on aluminum adaptors and ran them across my Tru Angle file set for 3 blade heads. This put the weight to approx 155 grains, just right for my setup. For someone on a budget there are plenty options for the thrifty archer.

From: the Black Spot
Date: 30-Jan-23

the Black Spot's embedded Photo



My son brought over those YS broadheads. Not quite the quality of the ma-3, but not too bad. They came in a box that said “Miller ski” on it. They weigh 190 gr. He got 20 of them for $1.25 ea

From: Corax_latrans
Date: 30-Jan-23




“He got 20 of them for $1.25 ea”

The squirrels are gonna hate that…..

From: the Black Spot
Date: 31-Jan-23




Gonna shoot one into some wood and see how they hold up. Son wanted to use them for hogs

From: the Black Spot
Date: 01-Feb-23

the Black Spot's embedded Photo



Looks like a “one and done” head

From: raghorn
Date: 01-Feb-23




over 5000 know broadheads on ABCC master list. You wonder why so many and did some good ones go away. BHD quality like the head above is why many heads are gone. Other reason is marketing, or manufacturing cost, or builder loses interest, retires, or passes.





If you have already registered, please

sign in now

For new registrations

Click Here




Visit Bowsite.com A Traditional Archery Community Become a Sponsor
Stickbow.com © 2003. By using this site you agree to our Terms and Conditions and our Privacy Policy