Traditional Archery Discussions on the Leatherwall


Death of Hollow Limb

Messages posted to thread:
SteelyDan 25-Sep-23
SteelyDan 25-Sep-23
SteelyDan 25-Sep-23
SteelyDan 25-Sep-23
wooddamon1 25-Sep-23
Orion 25-Sep-23
bentstick54 25-Sep-23
Stoner 25-Sep-23
Runner 26-Sep-23
Buzz 26-Sep-23
4nolz@work 26-Sep-23
tradslinger 26-Sep-23
aromakr 26-Sep-23
Kelly 26-Sep-23
bugsy 49 26-Sep-23
SteelyDan 26-Sep-23
PEARL DRUMS 26-Sep-23
PA Bones 26-Sep-23
Arvin 26-Sep-23
From: SteelyDan
Date: 25-Sep-23

SteelyDan's embedded Photo



I had some bad luck in selfbow building two years ago, breaking four in a row for various reasons. My last seven have turned out successfull; bows of black locust, yew billets, oso berry and two Osage.

For fun I thought to try a hollow limb design of yew. I got it to bending on the tiller tree to 14" and it was looking good.

From: SteelyDan
Date: 25-Sep-23

SteelyDan's embedded Photo



I measured and shaped, flipped the tips slightly and started to hollow the limb belly to match the back. I left the tips wide in case I needed some string alignment later. I glued on temporary nocks.

From: SteelyDan
Date: 25-Sep-23

SteelyDan's embedded Photo



It was bending nicely in the vice. On a long string it bent nice and even on the tiller tree.

I got a long string on it and flexed and exercised to even limb bend. It was bending to 14" on the tiller tree.

I went to put the long string on and was using the step through method to get the string on. We'll........CRACK!

From: SteelyDan
Date: 25-Sep-23

SteelyDan's embedded Photo



They say if you want to be a successful bowyer, you can't be a quitter! I have one more good stave left in the hayloft and two yew billets ready to go.

Time to try again I guess.

SD

From: wooddamon1 Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 25-Sep-23




Bummer!

From: Orion Professional Bowhunters Society - Qualified Member Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 25-Sep-23




Might try a little shallower hollow on the next one. Good luck.

From: bentstick54
Date: 25-Sep-23




That’s too bad. I’ve never attempted a hollow limb design myself. You definitely had a lot of work in it at that point.

From: Stoner
Date: 25-Sep-23




Been there, done that. sucks, but still learning. John

From: Runner
Date: 26-Sep-23




I see no good reason to make hollow limb bows.

From: Buzz
Date: 26-Sep-23




Damn.

From: 4nolz@work
Date: 26-Sep-23




every one is a learning experience but hollow might be redesigning the wheel

From: tradslinger
Date: 26-Sep-23




Not for me, I have enough challenges as it is. Sorry to see it happen to you, I have broken a few bows myself.

From: aromakr Professional Bowhunters Society - Qualified Member
Date: 26-Sep-23




I'd dribble some thin epoxy into the crack like West Systems clamp it together and see if salvageable.

Bob

From: Kelly
Date: 26-Sep-23




WHY?

From: bugsy 49
Date: 26-Sep-23




Glue, and patch the crack with thin strips of wood on belly, and back. It is worth a try. Yew is hard to come by, and expensive. Good luck.

From: SteelyDan
Date: 26-Sep-23




No, it's kindling now I think.

Feedback from a friendly bowyer suggests that the edges were too thick and that the middle of the limb wanted to bend but the edges did not. He suggested more of a knife edge design.

My thoughts were that I had only started the bending process and that I was still safe in the tillering. Obviously not! I have had limbs break before but never stem to stern.

SD

From: PEARL DRUMS
Date: 26-Sep-23




That's not repairable. I would cut that other limb off and use it down the road. Either a splice job or a sleeve set.

From: PA Bones Professional Bowhunters Society - Associate Member
Date: 26-Sep-23




Too bad. I’ve had more trouble with yew than any other selfbow wood

From: Arvin
Date: 26-Sep-23




I’d rather trap the back to reduce mass instead of hollowing the belly. . That’s just me.





If you have already registered, please

sign in now

For new registrations

Click Here




Visit Bowsite.com A Traditional Archery Community Become a Sponsor
Stickbow.com © 2003. By using this site you agree to our Terms and Conditions and our Privacy Policy