Traditional Archery Discussions on the Leatherwall


You have to pick one

Messages posted to thread:
altitude sick 25-May-20
GF 25-May-20
YH2268 25-May-20
Rick 3 25-May-20
Nrthernrebel05 25-May-20
Ben 25-May-20
AK Pathfinder 25-May-20
Backcountry 25-May-20
fdp 25-May-20
PECO 25-May-20
1Longbow 25-May-20
3Ditional 25-May-20
GF 25-May-20
Pdiddly 25-May-20
GLF 25-May-20
Mortis Sagittas 25-May-20
Joe2Crow 25-May-20
newt 25-May-20
Heat 25-May-20
Outwest on laptop 25-May-20
Mike E 25-May-20
Barber 26-May-20
msinc 26-May-20
MStyles 26-May-20
Paul Fithian 26-May-20
Jeff Durnell 26-May-20
Brad Lehmann 26-May-20
Curtis Schaffhauser 26-May-20
Curtis Schaffhauser 26-May-20
Curtis Schaffhauser 26-May-20
Curtis Schaffhauser 26-May-20
Tom McCool 26-May-20
George D. Stout 26-May-20
mangonboat 26-May-20
RJH1 26-May-20
crookedstix 26-May-20
goldentrout_one 26-May-20
Codjigger 26-May-20
Wayne Hess 26-May-20
NE Archer 26-May-20
George D. Stout 26-May-20
Buckeye 26-May-20
76aggie 26-May-20
Stickbow Felty 26-May-20
Stickbow Felty 26-May-20
altitude sick 26-May-20
Bassman 26-May-20
T4halo 26-May-20
Jim 26-May-20
Wudstix 26-May-20
OldBeginner55 27-May-20
wingman 16-Jun-20
TradToTheBone 16-Jun-20
Babbling Bob 16-Jun-20
altitude sick 16-Jun-20
redheadlover 16-Jun-20
2 bears 16-Jun-20
2 bears 16-Jun-20
stagetek 16-Jun-20
Bowbaker 16-Jun-20
Leathercutter 16-Jun-20
Orion 16-Jun-20
Jason D 17-Jun-20
Buzz 17-Jun-20
Dale Rohrbeck 17-Jun-20
Babbling Bob 17-Jun-20
Bellaodin 17-Jun-20
Curt 17-Jun-20
Wapiti - - M. S. 17-Jun-20
From: altitude sick
Date: 25-May-20




54 or 62” Wing Thunderbird pre AMF

Bear Kodiak any year

Damon Howatt Hunter

From: GF
Date: 25-May-20




How lucky am I to own 2 of the above??? The T-bird (‘67) and a Hunter (‘90).

The Hunter may be a little plain to some, but she was my first... And honestly - at 62” and about #54 off of my fingers - I have never had a truly compelling reason to buy anything else since. They’re just fun.

From: YH2268 Professional Bowhunters Society - Qualified Member Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 25-May-20




I'll play - 64 Bear Kodiak - just cause I got one.

From: Rick 3
Date: 25-May-20




I absolutely love my '65 Kodiak! Shoots like a dream.

I love the Wings and the Howatt's, but my Kodiak is insane!

From: Nrthernrebel05
Date: 25-May-20




Tough choice. I’d have to go with the Hunter

From: Ben
Date: 25-May-20




62" Wing Thunderbird. The Hunter I had I didn't care for it was smooth but the sight window didn't work for me. I've had Kodiak Hunters and Super Kodiaks and the are just okay. Never had a straight Kodiak.

From: AK Pathfinder
Date: 25-May-20




I have the old Bears but the Hunter...I'll take it.

From: Backcountry
Date: 25-May-20




i shoot my H-Hunters better than my T-bird. The T-bird is a project bow, trying to get the grip to point where I’m looking. The Hunters already do...

From: fdp
Date: 25-May-20




Howatt Hunter.

From: PECO
Date: 25-May-20




Hunter

From: 1Longbow
Date: 25-May-20




Hunter

From: 3Ditional
Date: 25-May-20




I'll go with the Hunter as well. Like the grip and feel of the shot.

From: GF
Date: 25-May-20




‘Cuz after all, we did all agree that the Howatt IS the greatest production bow of all time....

From: Pdiddly
Date: 25-May-20

Pdiddly's embedded Photo



I was shooting my 62" bowling ball Thunderbird and my 1962 Howatt Hunter last week...both were the same draw...51#, so used the same arrows.

The TBird is just like a Cadillac...heavy to carry but steady due to the weight and plunks them right in....very quick and stable. It had a Fury string on it so quiet as well. I have a 52" but don't like it as much.

The knife edge Hunter was like a part of my arm...and quick as well. Very smooth on the draw, like the Thunderbird.

The Howatt would be my pick...but that T-Bird is not far off the mark.

3rd would be my 1957 Kodiak Special that's 62" and 52#. It's a beautiful bow to shoot. And to look at so it gets a picture!

From: GLF
Date: 25-May-20




Hunter

From: Mortis Sagittas
Date: 25-May-20




Wish I could play... but I only have 55' Kodiak special. Really like it though from posts on here the other two may well knock it's socks off.

From: Joe2Crow
Date: 25-May-20

Joe2Crow's embedded Photo



Hunter, as long as it is a rosewood or purpleheart model

From: newt
Date: 25-May-20




Howatt Hunter

From: Heat
Date: 25-May-20




Kodiak

From: Outwest on laptop
Date: 25-May-20




H. Hunter by far my favorite bow. For me it shoots circles around all of my more expensive bows.

From: Mike E
Date: 25-May-20




Somethin' from the 50's 62-64" with static tips.

From: Barber
Date: 26-May-20




Damon Howatt Hunter

From: msinc
Date: 26-May-20




I'd take the Kodiak, probably replace the early 90's "camo" one I had. But, the more I keep hearing about the Hunter it's looking like I will have to have one soon...which one and/or year is considered the "most desirable"????

From: MStyles
Date: 26-May-20




Wing bc I never had one.

From: Paul Fithian
Date: 26-May-20

Paul Fithian's embedded Photo



Thunderbird

From: Jeff Durnell Professional Bowhunters Society - Associate Member
Date: 26-May-20




I honestly couldn't choose one above the others. I'm just not a production bow kind of guy, don't own one, don't want one.

From: Brad Lehmann
Date: 26-May-20




Make mine a 1959 Kodiak in 64" length

From: Curtis Schaffhauser
Date: 26-May-20




57 Kodiak here.

From: Curtis Schaffhauser
Date: 26-May-20




57 Kodiak here.

From: Curtis Schaffhauser
Date: 26-May-20




57 Kodiak here.

From: Curtis Schaffhauser
Date: 26-May-20




Oops!

From: Tom McCool
Date: 26-May-20




71 Kodak Hunter

From: George D. Stout
Date: 26-May-20




So now you're pi#%ed off Ernie Root and Ben Pearson by keeping them fron the equation. Not to mention Earl Hoyt, Jr. and sundry other bowyers/manufacturers of the day. Watch out for that bolt of lightning from the archery heavens. ;)

From: mangonboat
Date: 26-May-20




What pdiddly said...and what GDS said. That's why I don't make those hard choices. If I could only have one, though...say, to fight zombies with, I'd take the 62" T-bird. If I ran out of arrows, I couldnt bring myself to whack anything in the head with a 1962 Hunter, and the Kodiaks don't have enough oomph, but one good swing of that massive phenolic riser could take down a monster....and never worry about a coin coming loose.

From: RJH1
Date: 26-May-20




I have a hunter and a kodiak and both have their merits and faults. One day i prefer one and the next the other. I lean towards the Hunter because I was the first bow i bought, but if it snapped in half the next time i drew it, i would buy the first reasonable priced Hunter or Kodiak in the same weight and not worry about it or think i was missing out. I have only had one wing and didn't love it, but honestly can't remember the model

From: crookedstix
Date: 26-May-20




The Hunter, but only because I prefer its riser weight, looks, performance, craftsmanship, and history. Other than that, it's a close contest, heheh. And Harold Groves's ghost wants a piece of the original poster, as well!

From: goldentrout_one
Date: 26-May-20




62" Thunderbird would be my first pick - I might go for the Howatt, but depends on the year.

From: Codjigger
Date: 26-May-20




I had the Howatt..good bow but I sold it. My 54' T Bird...never! Sandy

From: Wayne Hess
Date: 26-May-20




Joe2Crow’s Howatt Hunter in left hand, 45#. I like.

From: NE Archer
Date: 26-May-20




Hunter

From: George D. Stout
Date: 26-May-20




I think the Thunderbird was 52" and 62" until AMF took over ownership, then it becames a 54" and 62". The phenolic material went away and gave way to Wingwood...a resing impregnated wood. Feel free to correct me though, I'm not an expert on Wing.

From: Buckeye
Date: 26-May-20




hunter here

From: 76aggie
Date: 26-May-20




Hunter.

From: Stickbow Felty
Date: 26-May-20




67 Tbird here because that's what i have.

From: Stickbow Felty
Date: 26-May-20

Stickbow Felty's embedded Photo



From: altitude sick
Date: 26-May-20




George, I agree. I have a ridiculously fancy riser ROOT Target Master. Very fancy 68” 34# at 28” Root are great bows.

I use mine to practice form.

I would show it off but can’t seem to load pics from my IPhone

From: Bassman Professional Bowhunters Society - Qualified Member
Date: 26-May-20




Never go wrong with a Kodiak, or DH Hunter. To close to call.Buy them both.

From: T4halo
Date: 26-May-20

T4halo's embedded Photo



A 1959 64” 45# Kodiak.

From: Jim Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 26-May-20




That’s easy, the DH Hunter of course.

From: Wudstix Professional Bowhunters Society - Associate Member
Date: 26-May-20




1965 Damon Howatt Hunter 65#@28” that I let get away circa ‘96 and have bee looking for since.

From: OldBeginner55
Date: 27-May-20




DHH

From: wingman
Date: 16-Jun-20




I have a 62" T-Bird in phenolic and a Howatt Hunter (82 model)and would go with the Howatt Hunter but, it's a hard choice as both shoot equally well for me.

From: TradToTheBone
Date: 16-Jun-20




I own a 54” Thunderbird and a Martin Howatt Hunter.Not really an apples to apples comparison but I’d rather shoot the Martin. Never shot a 62” Thunderbird,maybe someday.

From: Babbling Bob Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 16-Jun-20




Shoot fire, that's simple as it gets. 1962 Kodiak, 'cause with its Brazilian rosewood riser, medium wrist, and limbs extended well into the riser, it would be the best looking one of all of'em all.

The Damon Howatt would be a surprisingly fast and comfortable bow by my experience as I acquired one once but gave it to my 15 year old brother-in-law to use. Always thought for a hunting bow bow it was some kind of super smooth shooter. Only other short bow I have owned which surprised me more was a 52-inch AMF Red Wing Hunter. It flat out spits them out like lightning.

From: altitude sick
Date: 16-Jun-20




Old Buck. and George

I agree. Pick 3 more closely performing bows from that era and lets carry it on.

From: redheadlover
Date: 16-Jun-20




LH 1966 64" 45+ pounds Kodiak

From: 2 bears
Date: 16-Jun-20




Every one should have a T-Bird but the DH Hunter hangs right in there too. >>>>-----> Ken

From: 2 bears
Date: 16-Jun-20

2  bears's embedded Photo



Oh! I forgot. My T-Bird >>>>-----> Ken

From: stagetek Professional Bowhunters Society - Qualified Member Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 16-Jun-20

stagetek's embedded Photo



1966. 64" Kodiak.

From: Bowbaker Professional Bowhunters Society - Qualified Member
Date: 16-Jun-20




I would have to pick the 62" Wing always loved Wing bows.

From: Leathercutter
Date: 16-Jun-20




I have to take the Wing. Had one and left it with a fellow Marine who was going to send it to my home as I was on surprise orders to Vietnam. It never got home. At least I got home from Nam.

From: Orion Professional Bowhunters Society - Qualified Member Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 16-Jun-20




I've owned or shot all of those. All good, but I'd take the Hunter.

From: Jason D
Date: 17-Jun-20




Got and have hade several of each.

Maybe 1960 or. 1962 Kodiak but THE GRIP of my 62” T-Bird is THE BEST!

Either way, 3rd would be my Hunter.

J.

From: Buzz
Date: 17-Jun-20

Buzz's embedded Photo



Can't pick.

I have all three.

From: Dale Rohrbeck
Date: 17-Jun-20




1962 66” Kodiak Special, Rosewood, mint green glass.

From: Babbling Bob Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 17-Jun-20




Think your very close Dale. My '62 63-inch Kodiak Special is a mighty special bow.

From: Bellaodin
Date: 17-Jun-20




First 59 Kodiak

Second DH Hunter

Third Wing Chapparal I'm not a big T-bird fan

From: Curt
Date: 17-Jun-20




Kodiak

From: Wapiti - - M. S. Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 17-Jun-20




Hunter





If you have already registered, please

sign in now

For new registrations

Click Here




Visit Bowsite.com A Traditional Archery Community Become a Sponsor
Stickbow.com © 2003. By using this site you agree to our Terms and Conditions and our Privacy Policy