Traditional Archery Discussions on the Leatherwall


Wood Arrow Questions?

Messages posted to thread:
Lastmohecken 10-Apr-24
fdp 10-Apr-24
Rooty 10-Apr-24
bentstick54 10-Apr-24
Matt B 10-Apr-24
jimwright 10-Apr-24
JusPassin 10-Apr-24
Mark 10-Apr-24
CStyles 10-Apr-24
Deno 10-Apr-24
Dan In MI 10-Apr-24
MarkL 10-Apr-24
Lastmohecken 10-Apr-24
Shootalot 10-Apr-24
Stumpkiller 10-Apr-24
Maclean 11-Apr-24
Maclean 11-Apr-24
Orion 11-Apr-24
dnovo 11-Apr-24
oldhunter1942 11-Apr-24
Lastmohecken 11-Apr-24
From: Lastmohecken
Date: 10-Apr-24




I have recently just got back into making some wood arrows and bought some Doug fir because that was really the only thing available, in town, at the moment. And I needed some arrows right away.

But I intend to order some more shafts soon, and on these Surewood Doug fir, Hunter grade arrows, I have noticed some difficulty in tapering, with the wood shavings not coming off leaving a clean end. Doug fir seems to grab and crumble pretty easy when using my pencil type tapering tool. I have read that about Doug fir, before. But these are very good arrows, otherwise, very straight, etc.

Advice? I need a tough, arrow that can stand some abuse.

From: fdp
Date: 10-Apr-24




You need to buy or build a power taper toll or buy a quality hand taper tool. Personally I think the power tool is the only way to go, but there are folks here who are fond of the higher quality hand tools.

From: Rooty
Date: 10-Apr-24




The perfect taper tool. Or sanding disc.

From: bentstick54
Date: 10-Apr-24




I have not built a jig for tapering 9” or 10” of the shaft, but built one that fits on my 10” Dewalt table saw and have a 10” sanding disc that I do my 5 and 11 degree tapers on. The grain on DF is not conducive to any knive blade type of tool that I’ve have ever tried.

From: Matt B
Date: 10-Apr-24




I never got a good taper on Doug fir until I got a Woodchuck. I have been told by people who use them that the Perfect Taper Tool also works well. I tried other blade tools without good results.

From: jimwright
Date: 10-Apr-24




if you order from Surewood, Carson can put the nock and point tapers on as can many Surewood dealers. You just need to provide the throat of nock to back of point length that you need.

From: JusPassin
Date: 10-Apr-24




bentstick54 x2

From: Mark
Date: 10-Apr-24




I regularly get Doug Fir shafts from Surewood. I get good results using a Woodchuck to taper shafts.

From: CStyles
Date: 10-Apr-24




I use the little black plastic Bearpaw taper tool on my Surewood shafts. It works

From: Deno
Date: 10-Apr-24




I use the same plastic taper tool as CStyles. I use it in the woods also. Works for me.

From: Dan In MI
Date: 10-Apr-24

Dan In MI's embedded Photo



I’m working on one like this.

From: MarkL
Date: 10-Apr-24




Dan, that looks great! Are you considering making some for sale?

From: Lastmohecken
Date: 10-Apr-24




Thank you guys. It's good to see what others do.

So, is Doug fir superior to most other arrow woods? I am assuming it must be based on how many of you have went to a fair amount of trouble, to get set up to taper them.

From: Shootalot
Date: 10-Apr-24




It's hard to beat a disk sander set up.

From: Stumpkiller
Date: 10-Apr-24




I have a Woodchuck Taper Tool for the nock & head tapers of my Douglas fir shafts. I hand taper the last 10" from 11/32" to 5/16" with a Dean Torges Bowyer's Edge taper tool (razor plane) and a jig I made out of hard maple.

From: Maclean Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 11-Apr-24




Dan, that's a sweet rig!

From: Maclean Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 11-Apr-24




Lastmohecken, IMO doug fir has advantages over cedar in strength, straightness, grain structure and overall quality & consistency of the shafts (thanks Surewood). It tends to be heavier than cedar, which I see as an advantage for my hunting arrows. The only disadvantage is not being able to use the pencil sharpener type taper tools for points and nocks.

From: Orion Professional Bowhunters Society - Qualified Member Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 11-Apr-24




Doug fir is an excellent arrow wood. I agree that it's stronger than cedar, and a bit heavier, but not with better grain or straighter than POC. The latter two characteristics depend on the manufacturer, and admittedly good POC is becoming hard to find nowadays, but there's still some around. Surewood shafts are consistently high quality. I've come across some other Dug fir that wasn't as good. Hardwoods are stronger yet, but they're too heavy for some tastes, and they are more difficult to keep straight.

From: dnovo Professional Bowhunters Society - Qualified Member Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 11-Apr-24




I bought my Woodchuck taper jig probably 30 years ago. One of my best investments. Back then I used it on cedar, ash, and maple shafts which was before Surewood came around with the fine fir shafts they sell. Now I use mostly cedar because I have a lot of shafts but I do use some fir arrows.

From: oldhunter1942
Date: 11-Apr-24




Check the blade sharpnes, I need to change the blade more often on Douglas Fir

From: Lastmohecken
Date: 11-Apr-24




I was able to do a good enough job at tapering the both the point and nock ends of a few Doug firs, with my pencil sharpener, purchased from three rivers many years ago.

I wondered about checking the blades for sharpness, as they are probably duller than they should be.

But I guess I need to get or make a better system, for the Doug firs.





If you have already registered, please

sign in now

For new registrations

Click Here




Visit Bowsite.com A Traditional Archery Community Become a Sponsor
Stickbow.com © 2003. By using this site you agree to our Terms and Conditions and our Privacy Policy