Traditional Archery Discussions on the Leatherwall


Selfbow Burnish

Messages posted to thread:
SteelyDan 14-Dec-23
Jeff Durnell 14-Dec-23
fdp 14-Dec-23
smrobertson 14-Dec-23
Jeff Durnell 14-Dec-23
fdp 14-Dec-23
Jeff Durnell 14-Dec-23
Jeff Durnell 14-Dec-23
fdp 14-Dec-23
SteelyDan 14-Dec-23
fdp 14-Dec-23
Jeff Durnell 14-Dec-23
SteelyDan 14-Dec-23
wooddamon1 14-Dec-23
bugsy 49 14-Dec-23
MStyles 15-Dec-23
Eric Krewson 15-Dec-23
SteelyDan 15-Dec-23
horseapple 16-Dec-23
BowAholic 16-Dec-23
Stoner 16-Dec-23
Arvin 17-Dec-23
arrow jock 17-Dec-23
fdp 17-Dec-23
arrow jock 17-Dec-23
From: SteelyDan
Date: 14-Dec-23




I am just finishing up a yew longbow. It is 64" long and 40#@26". It is all tillered and ready for finishing.

My question to bowyers is whether or not I should burnish the bow. I have several other yew bows that I have not burnished and they are fine. I have made one osage that I did burnish.

Is there a palpable benefit to burnishing a bow made of soft yew wood? Are there dangers to doing this?

Thanks, SD

From: Jeff Durnell
Date: 14-Dec-23




I've burnished a few and others I didn't, and haven't noticed much practical difference. It does smooth and slightly compress the fibers of the outermost surface, and theoretically at least should make the yew a 'little' more impervious, but so does a good finish. I do like how it looks and feels after burnishing.

From: fdp
Date: 14-Dec-23




I burnish all my wooden bows and all my wooden arrows.

From: smrobertson
Date: 14-Dec-23




How do you put on a burnish?

From: Jeff Durnell
Date: 14-Dec-23




Burnishing is done after final sanding by rubbing the wood with a smooth piece of antler, bone, steel rod, etc. It will get glossy, and glass smooth, and it compresses the surface of the wood. The finish is applied afterwards.

From: fdp
Date: 14-Dec-23




I do it with the shank of a screw driver.

Rub it over the surface using a considerable amount of pressure. You can see the wood compress and the surface become shiny.

From: Jeff Durnell
Date: 14-Dec-23




I use steel also Frank. I use a piece of 1" diameter stainless rod a bit less than a foot long. It has some heft so I don't really apply much if any downward pressure.

From: Jeff Durnell
Date: 14-Dec-23




I've also used an actual 'burnisher', made to roll the edge on a cabinet scraper. They burnish wood too. But yes, a screwdriver shank works just the same.

From: fdp
Date: 14-Dec-23




"piece of 1" diameter stainless rod a bit less than a foot long."

That would be darn handy.

From: SteelyDan
Date: 14-Dec-23




I just now finished the final sanding (600 grit). I burned in the nock grooves and marked (wrote) on the bottom limb the bows specs.

It's smooth as silk and I am happy with it. I think that I will just go ahead and finish with True oil rather than go to the work/risk of burnishing; especially if there is no noticeable difference in performance or durability.

Thanks all for your input. I will post a pic when it's all done.

SD

From: fdp
Date: 14-Dec-23




"performance or durability."...personally I'm pretty well convinced that it does increase durability by compressing the fibers and making them less likely to raise. But that's just me.

And there is no risk.....

From: Jeff Durnell
Date: 14-Dec-23




And depending on how hard the burnishing is done, it may also help with durability in the sense of scrapes, denting, and such... some... it won't turn yew into osage, but...

Good yew isn't as soft as many folks think. It's actually more dense than some hardwoods.

From: SteelyDan
Date: 14-Dec-23




Thanks for that information Frank. I will walk around the bow for a day or two before proceeding. Maybe other self bowyers can comment.

I am in no rush to see it finished.

SD

From: wooddamon1 Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 14-Dec-23




Looking forward to seeing your new bow, haven't worked with yew yet.

From: bugsy 49
Date: 14-Dec-23




I also burnish all my wood bows. I made an Ojibwa bow from blue beech that looks like it is made from bone. No brainer for me.

From: MStyles
Date: 15-Dec-23




I have burnished arrow shafts with a Butchers smooth steel. The kind that they use in packing houses to maintain a very fine edge on their boning knives.

From: Eric Krewson
Date: 15-Dec-23




I have made a lot of wood bows. I burnished the first few because that is what the books told me to do. I found it to be an unnecessary step that doesn't hurt or help the longevity of a bow.

Nothing wrong with burnishing a bow if that is your choice, have at it.

There are a lot of old wives' tales in bow making that keep being passed down.

My dad died at 100 years old 5 or 6 years ago, he was old enough to remember when baseball players kept a hambone in the dugout to burnish their bats to hopefully keep them from breaking so easily.

I don't think there are any hambones in the dugouts today.

From: SteelyDan
Date: 15-Dec-23




Good story Eric...and puts things in perspective. I went ahead and burnished the bow this morning and I must say it looks better. It did appear to compress some surface fibers and the bow shines like it was Minwaxed!

Whether it actually aides in longevity only time will tell...but it sure looks good.

Thank you all for your input.

SD

From: horseapple
Date: 16-Dec-23




All baseball bats are burnished in the making. I still burnish my bows mainly because it hardens the outer skin.

From: BowAholic
Date: 16-Dec-23




This is an interesting thread. thanks. Good to see you posting JD. I don't burnish, but maybe I should. It just seemed like I spend the entire build trying to prevent crushing grain and taking set...only to crush grain and burnish? It does look good though... :)

From: Stoner
Date: 16-Dec-23




After my final sanding with 600 grit I burnish with an old olive oil bottle. John

From: Arvin
Date: 17-Dec-23




I use to burnish but when i started getting better wood I got away from it. I think I will go back to it though. It helps with pin knots most likely.

From: arrow jock
Date: 17-Dec-23




Might be a stupid question but, burnish the whole bow or just the back?

From: fdp
Date: 17-Dec-23




Not a stupid question. You can do either.

From: arrow jock
Date: 17-Dec-23




Thanks





If you have already registered, please

sign in now

For new registrations

Click Here




Visit Bowsite.com A Traditional Archery Community Become a Sponsor
Stickbow.com © 2003. By using this site you agree to our Terms and Conditions and our Privacy Policy