Traditional Archery Discussions on the Leatherwall


Beman Centershot Arrows, Experiences?

Messages posted to thread:
YamahaYG68 14-Oct-19
9/10 Broke 14-Oct-19
Flyman 14-Oct-19
George D. Stout 14-Oct-19
hawkeye in PA 14-Oct-19
YamahaYG68 14-Oct-19
YamahaYG68 14-Oct-19
YamahaYG68 14-Oct-19
George D. Stout 14-Oct-19
fdp 14-Oct-19
BigHorn 14-Oct-19
goldentrout_one 14-Oct-19
deerfly 15-Oct-19
Horseman308 16-Oct-19
Hookedspur 16-Oct-19
Hookedspur 16-Oct-19
YamahaYG68 16-Oct-19
bergie 16-Oct-19
Bucbuster 16-Oct-19
Bucbuster 16-Oct-19
deerfly 17-Oct-19
Therifleman 17-Oct-19
Bassman 17-Oct-19
YamahaYG68 17-Oct-19
sheepdogreno 17-Oct-19
sheepdogreno 17-Oct-19
YamahaYG68 17-Oct-19
sheepdogreno 17-Oct-19
BigJim 31-Oct-19
PIRA Dad 01-Nov-19
Jay B 01-Nov-19
From: YamahaYG68
Date: 14-Oct-19




Anyone here have any experiences, good, or bad, with Beman Centershots?

https://beman.com/beman_products/centershot/

Especially interested in fellow light draw weight archers shooting 30" to 31" 600's.

From: 9/10 Broke Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 14-Oct-19




I am shooting 600 Centershots at 29 1/2" with 75 gn brass insert and 125 gn head out of a 40@28 recurve. I've only shot 1 deer with this set-up though so I am early in the trial process. I believe I would have had a pass through but hit the off side shoulder on a 140 pound deer. I had been shooting full length 500's out of a 45@28 recurve and all were complete pass throughs but one that hit the off shoulder.

Like I say it's early in the trial process but I believe it's gonna work fine.

From: Flyman
Date: 14-Oct-19




Great arrows.Really like the thin diameter and penetration you get from the thin diameter.

From: George D. Stout Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 14-Oct-19




I believe that Easton makes them so I would expect a very good quality shaft. What do you mean by lightweight? 40#? 30#. The normal here is for guys to buy a spine too stiff and then weight the tips down, so it's important to know your weight before we advise any spine.

From: hawkeye in PA
Date: 14-Oct-19




I've been shooting them for quite a few years, no complaints. Not unbreakable but they really stand up to abuse.

From: YamahaYG68
Date: 14-Oct-19




"What do you mean by lightweight? 40#? 30#."

I am doing some preliminary checking.

I have an Omega Imperial 68", on order, it has been ordered in 30# @ 30". Kegan says these are cut to center, although I am assuming a strike plate will reduce this, a bit.

Use will be solely recreational shooting and 3D out to a max of 30 yards.

My goal is to have a decent arrow that is not so expensive it spoils the day to lose or break one.

Not afraid to weight them up a bit, if needed.

From: YamahaYG68
Date: 14-Oct-19




In addition, I am not stuck on Beman Centershots, I have been looking around at options.

From: YamahaYG68
Date: 14-Oct-19




For something totally different, the 3 Rivers Spine Calc. indicate that an XX75 Platinum 1813 with 100 grain points might work, thought the thinner wall aluminium might be prone to dents and bending.

I have a very good Arten Arrowset starightener that I have had for years, it is good for checking suspect shafts and can straighten some that are bent, successfully.

From: George D. Stout Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 14-Oct-19




If you want carbons for 3D or target, look at the 700 at 31" and 100 grain tips. I would think 600 wold require more tip weight and not give you the best trajectory. I wouldn't even dismiss the idea of an 800 in carbon. You could try a 1716, or 1814 (X7 material) aluminum too but I think they come 30" full length.

From: fdp
Date: 14-Oct-19




Id go with Big Jims Dark Timber shafts (although that isn't what you asked). The spine choices are very wide and the price is really hard to beat.

From: BigHorn
Date: 14-Oct-19




ive been very happy with the bemans, i think the axis insert design especially with the collar makes for tougher arrow but the bemans are good. bigjims arrow look like a hell of deal too. i wouldnt hesitate on any of them

From: goldentrout_one
Date: 14-Oct-19




I have some 400s, my first carbons (I have always been an aluminum guy). They seem like pretty nice arrows and are fairly durable, although I did have one break in half just in front of the feathers (I still don't know how that happened), and I smashed another one in an attempt to shoot through an iron maiden, but I don't think any arrow would survive an impact against a steel plate. They are painted, so the finish can get chipped. Overall, if I was to switch over to carbon, I'd probably do the center-shot. The people I shoot with seem to prefer the Goldtip trads because they can put an aluminum footer on the tip that helps the shaft survive hard impacts..... but the center-shot seems to do almost as well.

From: deerfly
Date: 15-Oct-19

deerfly's embedded Photo



Just started using them April of this year. Absolutely love them and they work pretty good too. :)

From: Horseman308
Date: 16-Oct-19




I used Centershots (500 spine, 30", 50g insert, and 150g tips) in my Bear TD, which is 42# @ 28" (I draw 29.5"). They flew fine. I had no complaints. Those were more of an experiment than anything. I use Big Jim's Dark Timber now and love them. But I have nothing bad to say about the Centershots.

From: Hookedspur Professional Bowhunters Society - Qualified Member Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 16-Oct-19

Hookedspur's embedded Photo



400 Centershots. Complete pass through

From: Hookedspur Professional Bowhunters Society - Qualified Member Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 16-Oct-19

Hookedspur's embedded Photo



From: YamahaYG68
Date: 16-Oct-19




Some good endorsements here.

I'll wait and see what the new Omega Imperial "likes", once I get here.

If its 600's, I will likely get some 600 Centershots, I do like my 500 ICS Hunter Classics; I have a couple bows that handle those quite well.

From: bergie
Date: 16-Oct-19




That's all I shoot and just love them fly nice and have great penetration. Bergie

From: Bucbuster
Date: 16-Oct-19




Great arrows. Only negative is the finish is not as durable as Heritage or Gold tip. Complete pass thru on a nice size Kansas buck last year and same on a doe I shot recently. 46-lbs@my draw length of 27.5". 500s

From: Bucbuster
Date: 16-Oct-19




Great arrows. Only negative is the finish is not as durable as Heritage or Gold tip. Complete pass thru on a nice size Kansas buck last year and same on a doe I shot recently. 46-lbs@my draw length of 27.5". 500s

From: deerfly
Date: 17-Oct-19




I have GT traditionals too, was shooting them before trying the Centershots. I haven't noticed any difference in finish durability. Purely anecdotal of course, but through normal use the finish doesn't seem any different to me.

From: Therifleman
Date: 17-Oct-19




With your bow weight and draw length i would give the dark timbers in 800 spine a try. You should be able to get a well tuned arrow with them at or below 10gpp. If you go w 600s my hunch is you'll have to load up the tip weight to the point where you'll be 14+ gpp which will really take a dive out past 18-20 yds. Ive had very dood results w the dark timbers and ce predator ii in 800 spine. The centershots are good shafts, but i think 600 will be a bit stiff for your set up.

From: Bassman Professional Bowhunters Society - Qualified Member
Date: 17-Oct-19




I bought 2 dozen Beman Hunters, 400, and 500 spine, and my son gave me some 400 center shot arrows.They are strong, durable, good shooting arrows, and I bought the shafts for 50 bucks a dozen at the time.

From: YamahaYG68
Date: 17-Oct-19




The Big Jim's Dark Timber shafts look interesting, too.

One concern I have is a quote from their website; "Currenty available until stock sells out."

Makes me wonder about availability if a person wants more shafts, or to replace lost or damaged arrows.

From: sheepdogreno
Date: 17-Oct-19




I’ve been shooting beman ics bowhunters for years and I haven’t found a better shaft for the money. I’m sure the center shots are great tko

From: sheepdogreno
Date: 17-Oct-19




I’ve been shooting beman ics bowhunters for years and I haven’t found a better shaft for the money. I’m sure the center shots are great tko

From: YamahaYG68
Date: 17-Oct-19




"I’ve been shooting beman ics bowhunters for year"

I am using them in 500's on some of my bows, now. I really like them. too.

From: sheepdogreno
Date: 17-Oct-19




Yea Yamaha I’ve found them more durable than gold tips. I draw almost 30 and I can get the 500s and 400s in 32in shafts

From: BigJim Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 31-Oct-19
BigJim is a Stickbow.com Sponsor - Website




YamahaYG68, the beman centershots are great arrows and for $69.99 per dz, are hard to beat. That's our price by the way.

The Dark Timbers will be available, but I'm currently learning on how quickly I need to re order to maintain a "always" in stock quantity. They sell so quickly for me, that I have a hard time knowing how many to order at a time. The first 480 dz sold in 8 weeks. The next order was a 1000 dz and they too are going fast. As you could imaging, this is a large up front investment.

Thanks, BigJim

From: PIRA Dad
Date: 01-Nov-19




I shoot both and like both but shoot 340's out of a 65# bow. That being said they are pile drivers and several guys at my bow club shoot them with 40 - 45lb recurves and LB. Can't go wrong with either IMO and if you are able to search the internet you can find them at pretty good prices.

From: Jay B
Date: 01-Nov-19




Got some 500s in a trade recently, they’re a fine arrow, just like all Bemans I’ve tried. I miss the MFX Classics though, they were some tough arrows.





If you have already registered, please

sign in now

For new registrations

Click Here




Visit Bowsite.com A Traditional Archery Community Become a Sponsor
Stickbow.com © 2003. By using this site you agree to our Terms and Conditions and our Privacy Policy