Traditional Archery Discussions on the Leatherwall


Why no love for longer longbows?

Messages posted to thread:
T4halo1 18-Jul-18
George D. Stout 18-Jul-18
gradymaci 18-Jul-18
Outlaw 18-Jul-18
Shooter 18-Jul-18
Tal McNeill 18-Jul-18
RonG 18-Jul-18
Gofish 18-Jul-18
jk 18-Jul-18
Cameron Root 18-Jul-18
Mountain Man 18-Jul-18
jk 18-Jul-18
Sam Dunham 18-Jul-18
Orion 18-Jul-18
Candyman 18-Jul-18
Buckdancer 18-Jul-18
bigdog21 18-Jul-18
Longtrad 18-Jul-18
George D. Stout 18-Jul-18
reb 18-Jul-18
David Mitchell 18-Jul-18
longbowguy 18-Jul-18
gradymaci 18-Jul-18
Tradarcher4fun 18-Jul-18
Barber 18-Jul-18
jk 18-Jul-18
Longtrad 18-Jul-18
Iwander 18-Jul-18
Iwander 18-Jul-18
Bender 18-Jul-18
bowhunt 18-Jul-18
JimPic 18-Jul-18
silverarrowhead 18-Jul-18
Tal McNeill 18-Jul-18
Jeff Durnell 19-Jul-18
Will tell 19-Jul-18
George D. Stout 19-Jul-18
Iwander 19-Jul-18
eddie c 19-Jul-18
David Mitchell 19-Jul-18
fdp 19-Jul-18
Roadrunner 19-Jul-18
David Mitchell 19-Jul-18
gradymaci 19-Jul-18
Sailor 19-Jul-18
Ovilla Bill 19-Jul-18
Hal9000 19-Jul-18
RonG 19-Jul-18
Iwander 19-Jul-18
2 bears 19-Jul-18
2 bears 19-Jul-18
RG 19-Jul-18
Justin 19-Jul-18
RonG 19-Jul-18
Douglas Tubbs 19-Jul-18
David Mitchell 19-Jul-18
gradymaci 19-Jul-18
David Mitchell 19-Jul-18
gradymaci 19-Jul-18
David Mitchell 20-Jul-18
Gnombre 20-Jul-18
picapica 20-Jul-18
Buzz 20-Jul-18
Phil 20-Jul-18
David Mitchell 20-Jul-18
Iwander 20-Jul-18
George D. Stout 20-Jul-18
George D. Stout 20-Jul-18
dean 20-Jul-18
Bernie P. 21-Jul-18
Hatchchaser 21-Jul-18
Redheadtwo 21-Jul-18
BOHO 23-Jul-18
dean 23-Jul-18
From: T4halo1
Date: 18-Jul-18




I've been shooting a 68" Blackhawk longbow by Jack Smith and like how forgiving it is. Zero handshock and smooth. But, everthing I see for sale are these 58 and 60 inch longbows. It's like folks have given up on longer bows. Why?

T4

From: George D. Stout Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 18-Jul-18




Lots of folks still shoot them yet, but there is just more to choose from. Couple that with the shorter 'longbows being more shooter-friendly, ala not harsh or jumpy and you have choices on both ends. It's good to have a lot of choices, but still lots of folks liking the long longbows.

From: gradymaci Professional Bowhunters Society - Associate Member
Date: 18-Jul-18




A long working limb that is not working due to draw length is why I stopped shooting them, but they looked Purty.

From: Outlaw
Date: 18-Jul-18




I shoot a 68” NM American,a 69” NM Shelton,and a 70” Hill Tembo and love shooting them all!!

From: Shooter
Date: 18-Jul-18




There is definitely somthing to be said about what Gradymaci said when you come to r/d bows. Now days I'm mostly a back yard and target shooter with a little small game hunting some times so I like shooting a longer bow.

From: Tal McNeill
Date: 18-Jul-18




One of my all-time favorite bows is my 70" 21st Century Edge. If you haven't shot one of these you're in for a real treat if you get your hands on one. Silky smooth, stable and fast, even at my wimpy 26.5 draw. Of course, it's got some serious R/D going on, thus the performance even at short draw.

From: RonG
Date: 18-Jul-18




I don't have a bow shorter than 68"

I never had a problem with the longer bows hunting, Florida is really a difficult place to get around in the swamps and muck bottoms.

I actually plan on making some longer ones, I just love the long bows, I don't like the shorter ones, 64" or less. Of course I am 6' 2" maybe that has something to do with it, but it doesn't matter I am a die-hard longbow person, longer the better.

Why you don't see the longer bows for sale is probably, they don't want to sell them, they are out there as George stated.

From: Gofish
Date: 18-Jul-18




I shot a 68" bamboo longhunter for years till I was told it's too long for my draw length and I bought several short longbows but I don't want any more short longbows

From: jk
Date: 18-Jul-18




I don't understand George's comment about longer longbows being less "shooter friendly."

From: Cameron Root
Date: 18-Jul-18




66" works best for me in an Asl. 26" draw. Rooty

From: Mountain Man
Date: 18-Jul-18




I prefer 66",,,but own 70-69-68-67-66-65" bows Whats your definition of a longer bow?

From: jk
Date: 18-Jul-18




My fave is a 66" Semtman.

From: Sam Dunham Professional Bowhunters Society - Associate Member
Date: 18-Jul-18




66 ich recurves, Warfs and 66 and 68 LB's. I have a 28 inch DL.

From: Orion Professional Bowhunters Society - Qualified Member Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 18-Jul-18




I don't accept the premise of your question. Maybe it's just the folks you hang around with. Lots of folks shoot longbows.

I suspect it's mostly recent converts who shoot the shorter hybrids, as much for their recurve like pistol grips as their shorter limbs.

Saw a member poll on the other site recently asking folks what they shot. I believe 55% said recurves, about 40% longbows and 5% self bows. Difficult to say how that 40% "longbow" shooters breaks down

However, seems to me there are about as many threads and for sale ads featuring longbows as hybrids.

From: Candyman
Date: 18-Jul-18




I have wondered about shooting a 68" bow with less then a 28" draw. As gradymaci mentioned, are you getting the same efficiency out of that limb but at a bit less draw weight? That has always kept me away from 68" bows. I usually shoot 64" or 66". Or does the design have more to do with it?

From: Buckdancer
Date: 18-Jul-18




That's BS. On longbows .it all depends on the taper of the limbs and the tiller you can keep your pigmy longbows

From: bigdog21
Date: 18-Jul-18




You may of answered your Owen question why do you see more short bows for sale ? people like there longbows and hanging on to them? the short hybrid bow flooded the market as the new thing and everyone likes to try new things. but many may be changing back to there old longbows and selling the short bow ? are the short bow is still the IN thing and no one can sell there longer bows without taking a beating on them so they are just keeping them?

From: Longtrad
Date: 18-Jul-18




I would guess there are more 58" 60" bows on the market because thats the length most bows are made these days

From: George D. Stout Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 18-Jul-18




jk, that isn't what I meant. What I was trying to say is the shorter ones have gotten better through design. In other words early models that were just short longbow designs could be 'kicky', but with the deflex/reflex designs of today the shorter bows are more user-friendly. That doesn't mean anything about the longer bows...they were mostly all relatively mild mannered anyway.

From: reb
Date: 18-Jul-18




I have a 68" Black Widow PLV that I love to shoot.

From: David Mitchell
Date: 18-Jul-18




I love my 68-70" "longbows".

From: longbowguy
Date: 18-Jul-18




There is a common notion that archers with short draws do better with short longbows. I have not found that to be so. I have 70" Hill bow that draws just 32#. It has performed very well in the hands of women, youths, and boys as young as about 9 years.

They generally love shooting such a manly looking bow. Being a Redman model made of yew it is also very handsome. I draw it to about 35# and it shoots a 420 grain arrow very well in my hands. I have heavier bows but I use this one a lot for general sport archery and form work.

So, short longbows do not make a lick of sense to me. - lbg

From: gradymaci Professional Bowhunters Society - Associate Member
Date: 18-Jul-18




My comment was like "I have a Corvette and like to drive it 20 mph" Those long-longbows are beautiful with the long legs or limbs, but drawing a 70" bow to 26" is well..Physics.. Anyways what do I know,I rode first seat on the short bus..

From: Tradarcher4fun
Date: 18-Jul-18




I love all my longbows - 56” to 68”. The 56” is just as smooth as the 68”.

From: Barber
Date: 18-Jul-18




My favorite is 66 inch. To be exact it is my 66 inch Freeman longbow .

From: jk
Date: 18-Jul-18




I don't shoot "efficiency".

From: Longtrad
Date: 18-Jul-18




I have a 54" pika that is one of my all time favorite bows, no shock and very smooth

From: Iwander
Date: 18-Jul-18




I have a 69" Jet Bison. Sweet bow!

From: Iwander
Date: 18-Jul-18

Iwander's embedded Photo



From: Bender
Date: 18-Jul-18




Love a "long" LB 66"+

And what is it you're seeing on those short lengths for sale? New or used? If used, ask yourself, why is the seller getting rid of it, almost always at a $ loss.

From: bowhunt
Date: 18-Jul-18




I think thiers a ton of guys who love shorter longbows and a ton of guys who love longer ones and just as many who love both.Thier really should be no real big debate about it.Shoot what you like.

From: JimPic
Date: 18-Jul-18




My favorite length is 66" at my 26½" draw, but I also shoot 67" and 68" ASL's. I have a few 64" Hill's but I don't shoot them nearly as much

From: silverarrowhead
Date: 18-Jul-18




Buckdancer is correct...

“That's BS. On longbows .it all depends on the taper of the limbs and the tiller you can keep your pigmy longbows”

From: Tal McNeill
Date: 18-Jul-18




What Buckdancer said. It depends on the limb design of the particular bow. With the 21st Edge, the longer limbs will perform better at any draw length than the shorter limbs (per the bowyer). I've owned 21st longbows in lengths from 64" to 70" and the longer bows outperform the shorter ones in every way. That would not hold true with longbows of a different limb design.

From: Jeff Durnell Professional Bowhunters Society - Associate Member
Date: 19-Jul-18




I have 58" through 72" longbows... with favorites throughout that range. To BE a favorite, there are several equally important factors and features that must have been considered and effectively coordinated along with draw length and bow length.

From: Will tell
Date: 19-Jul-18




I like short longbows and am using a 58" longbow, I have a 60", 62" and a 64" inch that I also shoot. I don't see much difference and shoot them all about the same. My problem is not the length but the handle, I can't seem to shoot a longbow with the straight grip.

From: George D. Stout Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 19-Jul-18




Jeff Durnell said: "I have 58" through 72" longbows... with favorites throughout that range. To BE a favorite, there are several equally important factors and features that must have been considered and effectively coordinated along with draw length and bow length."

That is a good answer right there. Add to the fact that somedays you just feel like shooting a different bow..length, etc. Variety, they say, is the spice of life.

From: Iwander
Date: 19-Jul-18




I can definitely shoot better under pressure with 69" plus ASLs and 66" Brack or Wes Wallace recurves.

From: eddie c
Date: 19-Jul-18




what bowhunt said. i came over to trad from a compound. i'm a bowhunter, not a target archer. i started bowhunting with a 40 something inch axial to axial bow. it was frustrating to carry a longer stickbow in the woods, snagging everything. i started with a recurve and now have a 64" selfbow. i had a 72" longbow at one time, shot 2 deer with it. but got tired of catching every twig within 3 feet of either side of me when going through the woods and went to a 60" LB shortly after.

From: David Mitchell
Date: 19-Jul-18




As usual, we are putting bows of the short, hybrid RD variety in with "real" longbows :o) concerning performance. My experience with what we have historically called a longbow is that when you get a bow of the ASL style down to a very short length--say 58-60" or so--they do not shoot well--not designed to shoot well at that length. ASL bows do much better in longer lengths--that's why they have been made that way for centuries.

From: fdp
Date: 19-Jul-18




I don't know why anyone would think there is no love for longer longbows. Even in a deflex/reflex design I prefer bows that are 64" or longer. Never really understood calling a 56 or 58" bow a longbow unless you are 4'10" tall. And yes....I know all the justification and, it makes -0- sense.

Longer bows, regardless of design alway increase the likelihood that we as archer's will shoot them more accurately and cosisstently.

And draw length haslittle to do with bow length if the bows is correctly made, and that is true of any bow design/profile.

From: Roadrunner
Date: 19-Jul-18




I always thought that the longer bows would be harder to get through the thickets. A few years ago I got a 68" ASL and found that it was actually easier to get through the thickets with it as opposed to a short recurve. I now shoot 66" recurves and 68" longbows because they are so SMOOTH.

From: David Mitchell
Date: 19-Jul-18




fdp, I think to some extent it's the "cool" factor. Longbows are just cooler than anything! Way cooler than saying "I shoot a RD bow that looks sort of like a recurve but is a longbow wannabe. LOL

From: gradymaci Professional Bowhunters Society - Associate Member
Date: 19-Jul-18




Wow..I Tap out of this one..

From: Sailor
Date: 19-Jul-18




I shoot 68 and 70 inch longbows. Don't think I would want anything under 68 inches.

From: Ovilla Bill
Date: 19-Jul-18




I shoot long bows from 62" to 66" in length. 68" and above were cumbersome in my truck and a pain when shipping. I was always worried about shutting my 68" Howard Hill bow in my truck door after a hunt when tired and snapping off a limb tip. My 27 and 3/4 inch draw allows me to shoot the shorter long bows without a problem so I sold my longer bows and moved on.

From: Hal9000
Date: 19-Jul-18




they were created so guys could by $50 small pop up blinds and hunt out of them :)

From: RonG
Date: 19-Jul-18




Variety, they say, is the spice of life. "QUOTE"

George, I told my girlfriend that and she didn't agree.

I will get out tuesday, won't be able to shoot or use the bathroom for a while, I will have to have my neighbor come over to tie my shoes and feed me.

George you need a sticker pasted on your posts, do not repeat what you read here, may be hazardous to your health.

I saw an opening George, just couldn't resist....Ha!Ha!

From: Iwander
Date: 19-Jul-18

Iwander's embedded Photo



These guys hunt in the thick jungle and feed their families with long longbows.

From: 2 bears
Date: 19-Jul-18




I still love them and have 4 in the 70" range. Smooth and quiet. I like stubby little bows too. >>>----> Ken

From: 2 bears
Date: 19-Jul-18




I still love them and have 4 in the 70" range. Smooth and quiet. I like stubby little bows too. >>>----> Ken

From: RG
Date: 19-Jul-18




I love to to shoot any bow. I find, for me, a shorter bow is easier to maneuver for the way I hunt. Climbing stands with rails or pop up ground blinds are what u use.

From: Justin
Date: 19-Jul-18




68” for me

From: RonG
Date: 19-Jul-18




four shooting at the same target, someone is bound to hit something.

Those fellas have a good idea, if your arrow is already 3/4ths of the way to the target you do have a better chance of hitting something also.

From: Douglas Tubbs
Date: 19-Jul-18




Those guys put the arch in archery!

From: David Mitchell
Date: 19-Jul-18




Grains per pound of bow weight for those guys????? I bet they didn't even bare shaft or paper tune. Don't they know that is all wrong the way they are doing it?

From: gradymaci Professional Bowhunters Society - Associate Member
Date: 19-Jul-18




I had a bow a missionary friend gave me that looked exactly like those.. Came with a sinew canaster shape holder for the different points made of bone and wood..1 point was dipped in a poison called karrarie if I spelled it right.. I asked him why the arrows were so long (4') and he said so they could find them when they shot, due to the jungle being so thick... Very interested story, he said they actually we're not very good shots but could ambush well to shoot at close distance and finished the animals off with a club..The bow is still on display with all the points and arrows at my Archery shop I sold..

From: David Mitchell
Date: 19-Jul-18




"Curare" comes from a vine widely grown in South America and acts to immobilize patients sometimes during very delicate surgery (or game). native people use it to immobilize game. Similar I guess to succinylcholine chloride used in the poison pods that they experimented with on arrows back in Fred Bear's day. Fred wanted nothing to do with it as applied to bowhunting. The stuff could just as easily immobilize and kill the user in the event of an accident. It would make it impossible to breathe. I sure hope the points on display in the archery shop you left behind don't have any left on them.

From: gradymaci Professional Bowhunters Society - Associate Member
Date: 19-Jul-18




Yep David that's it. The bow came from Papau New Guinea.. I think all the points are sealed up..He did say that they were more productive with a blow dart than a bow.. They shot a lot of monkey's he said..

From: David Mitchell
Date: 20-Jul-18




Monkeys! Oh yeah! I have a former student who came to the states from Peru to attend a college where I used to teach. He told me about hunting monkeys with an old single shot shotgun and said one day that if I came to Peru "I'll fix you some monkey meat." He never went back to Peru but stayed in the states and is pastor of a church here. Guess I won't be trying monkey meat any time soon. LOL Fine with me. :o)

From: Gnombre
Date: 20-Jul-18




"Pygmy Longbows"....This term just cracked me up. I own a 56" Javaman Elkheart that is a real joy to shoot, however after hearing this term I'm going to start referring to it as my Pygmy Longbow.

From: picapica
Date: 20-Jul-18




Per other comments, it appears that we keep the long ones and buy/sell the short ones. I'll never sell my 68" Wes Wallace Royal, but I have bought and sold several that were 64" or less.

From: Buzz
Date: 20-Jul-18

Buzz's embedded Photo



76".

From: Phil
Date: 20-Jul-18

Phil's embedded Photo



76 inch also

From: David Mitchell
Date: 20-Jul-18




picapica, I agree with you. I have owned and sold several short bows usually called "longbows" and currently do not own one, but I still have a rack of 66-69" ASLs.

From: Iwander
Date: 20-Jul-18




Very cool, Does winnie the pooh live in that tree?

From: George D. Stout Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 20-Jul-18




I think if you are getting caught up in the foliage with a long longbow, then you should just spend more time leaning how to not get caught up. I've hunting with 70" recurves in the thick areas here in Pa and it was never a problem. You do have to pay attention though and use a little common sense. Pretty easy to clear ahead of time for tree stand hunters...not excuse for them. And ground hunters....don't stop to shoot under low hanging limbs. That's pretty much it.

From: George D. Stout Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 20-Jul-18




Oh, and by the way, I have a 68" longbow, and two 60" models that we always called semi-recurves...but todays folks call them longbows as well.

From: dean
Date: 20-Jul-18




Something lives in that tree. Guy across the street stuck his arm in a hole in a tree to see what lived in it. Bats, lots of bats. The next week he had it cut down, there was six feet of bat poop in the hollow trunk, he only needed a 12" chain saw to cut it down and it broke into three linear trunks when it hit the ground. Being able to cant the bow makes using longer bows very doable in the thick stuff.

From: Bernie P.
Date: 21-Jul-18




My bows are recurve 62".Longbows 64" and 68".Hybrid 66".My favorite is the 68".I would never buy a longbow shorter than 64".Or a recurve shorter than 60".

From: Hatchchaser
Date: 21-Jul-18




Lots of short Longbows for sale. I do best with a 66”-68” mild R/D longbow yet I continue to try every new short, forward handle, good for long draw bow that comes out. Always end up selling them. One would think I’d learn my lesson. ?????

From: Redheadtwo
Date: 21-Jul-18




You shoot the long longbows (I've had 72" bows),you learn to cant the bow to not get tangled in brush. Or just take a knee to make a shot. Long longbows are sweet.

From: BOHO
Date: 23-Jul-18




for me its just not practical. its really thick where I hunt and it would be hitting everything. if I hunted in a pasture it would prolly be ok but most times I cant see 25 yards.

From: dean
Date: 23-Jul-18




I have always wanted to be able to hunt with a 50" or 48" recurve, I can see how handy they can be, but I have misses that are unacceptable past 20 yards with them. It is something that I do wrong when the heat is on, that does not seem to show up with longer bows. I find that a 62" r/d with a cant is much more predictable for me in tight quarters. Saying that, I have shot a number of deer shooting from my butt on the ground leaning against a tree with 68" longbows. That works quite well when shooting with any amount of down slope, but not so good when shooting up hill or across the slope to the bow hand side when bottom limb is up slope. It all comes down to simple things we need to work around on occasion.





If you have already registered, please

sign in now

For new registrations

Click Here




Visit Bowsite.com A Traditional Archery Community Become a Sponsor
Stickbow.com © 2003. By using this site you agree to our Terms and Conditions and our Privacy Policy