Traditional Archery Discussions on the Leatherwall


Enough for hogs?

Messages posted to thread:
Rhett Parish 07-Feb-16
Rhett Parish 07-Feb-16
cut it out 07-Feb-16
Dkincaid 07-Feb-16
Rhett Parish 07-Feb-16
BaconArrow 07-Feb-16
Lowcountry 07-Feb-16
Barber 07-Feb-16
Dkincaid 07-Feb-16
Rhett Parish 07-Feb-16
razorhead 07-Feb-16
Dry Bones 07-Feb-16
wmb238 07-Feb-16
Flash 07-Feb-16
Hector 08-Feb-16
SB 08-Feb-16
Stykman 08-Feb-16
Sawtooth 08-Feb-16
Rhett Parish 08-Feb-16
Dry Bones 08-Feb-16
Jim Casto Jr 08-Feb-16
trad47 08-Feb-16
Bob Hildenbrand 08-Feb-16
wmb238 08-Feb-16
Iwander 28-Feb-16
wifishkiller 28-Feb-16
RymanCat 29-Feb-16
TrapperKayak 29-Feb-16
TrapperKayak 29-Feb-16
Stykman 29-Feb-16
Arrowflinger 29-Feb-16
George D. Stout 29-Feb-16
Michael Schwister 29-Feb-16
From: Rhett Parish
Date: 07-Feb-16




45lb Kodiak mag I draw at 26.5 with 45-50 spine cedar shaft with 125 grain zwickey Eskimos enough for hogs?

From: Rhett Parish
Date: 07-Feb-16




The arrows are Cut 28.50 inches

From: cut it out
Date: 07-Feb-16




Yes and keep shots close

From: Dkincaid
Date: 07-Feb-16




It's not optimal but will work as long as you do your part

From: Rhett Parish
Date: 07-Feb-16




Also have a 50lb k-mag just shoot the 45 better just was wondering if my setup is good for hogs and whitetail?

From: BaconArrow
Date: 07-Feb-16




that will work perfect for Hogs, just hit your spots and keep the bacon under 100lbs and you will be good to go.

Shoot on a Line and bring home the Bacon,

From: Lowcountry
Date: 07-Feb-16




There are a thousand variables - but yes 45lbs will do the job.

From: Barber
Date: 07-Feb-16




That will be fine. It's like they always say , shot placement is everything .

From: Dkincaid
Date: 07-Feb-16




It's not really 45# more like 40#@26.5

From: Rhett Parish
Date: 07-Feb-16




Thanks guys

From: razorhead
Date: 07-Feb-16




my opinion, not really, hogs are tough, so get close, and they got great noses...... best shot is not behind the shoulder, but just above it, and I did it with a 45lb Hoyt Buffalo, and a Razor Cap, head, and the shot was 15 yards,,,,,,,,

this year I am using my Checkmate at 53 pounds,,,,,, even then I want to be close, and will be shooting a Magnus,,,,,

good luck and have fun

From: Dry Bones
Date: 07-Feb-16




Should do the job, but make sure you know your vitals. Razorhead, I tried pinning one to the ground via spine this past season, arrow could not have slid past by more then an inch, but she did get up and then the fun began. It will always cost you an arrow but a buddy of mine says he likes the soft behind the ear moving toward the forehead. Small target and need to be VERY close range.

-Bones

From: wmb238
Date: 07-Feb-16




Penetration could be an issue on a 300# ish boar hog.

From: Flash
Date: 07-Feb-16




Average hogs no problem. Large and Xlarge, very high probability you won't have very good penetration. On a big shielded boar you could make a great shot and only get one lung.

From: Hector
Date: 08-Feb-16




light low average performer bow at short draw and light arrow that's the perfect combo for hogs :-)

From: SB
Date: 08-Feb-16




;)

From: Stykman
Date: 08-Feb-16




Just put that broadhead in the right spot and you should do fine.

From: Sawtooth
Date: 08-Feb-16




Out of extreme curiosity, I wonder how many of you that posted have ever killed a pig. Flash- I agree with you completely.

From: Rhett Parish
Date: 08-Feb-16




I have killed several with heavier bows was just curious what the thoughts were with that set up.

From: Dry Bones
Date: 08-Feb-16




I've taken a few. My first bow kill was a pig. I think that first season I ended up with 5-6. I try not to let them get away without at least one staying whenever I see pigs.

-Bones

From: Jim Casto Jr
Date: 08-Feb-16




Sows and shoats will be no problem. I'd stay away from boars. :^)

From: trad47
Date: 08-Feb-16




A relative of ours who lives in South east Tx had one in a pen . It was was double fenced and boy it was one big pig Volkswagen sized. When I went to the fence it got up and charged with all it s might at the fence. Wouldn't want to face off with one in the woods. I'd need cannon to drop it. 45# bow??? Are you kidding? Make sure you have tree to climb up or have a backup with a 308. Serious .??

From: Bob Hildenbrand
Date: 08-Feb-16




I am shooting 480 grain Genesis arrows out of a 43# Groves Spitfire Magnum and I have no doubts that this combo will penetrate adequately at the ranges I shoot.

From: wmb238
Date: 08-Feb-16




I've taken 10 head, or a little better with a bow.

From: Iwander
Date: 28-Feb-16




Depends on the pig:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZ1Mg0a7Tpw

From: wifishkiller
Date: 28-Feb-16




I've shot a ton and you should be ok. Id front load a carbon shoot a 3 to 1 head and hit them low and tight to the shoulder and you'll be ok. Out of the 100 plus I've bow killed only one or 2 were worth talking about in slowing an arrow down.

From: RymanCat
Date: 29-Feb-16




Shaving sharp broad heads. Don't forget.LOL

Shoot for the battery box.LOL

From: TrapperKayak
Date: 29-Feb-16




That hog has rigor mortis, and the broad head is one of those piece of crap insert types, three blade, one of which came seperated, and the shot was high. Not surprised that arrow only went in three inches. True, the arrow needs to be heavier, but still it should have gone in further and would have with a live animal and a two blade head in that spot on the shoulder.

From: TrapperKayak
Date: 29-Feb-16




BTW, I'm referring to Iwander's youtube vid.

From: Stykman
Date: 29-Feb-16




I just watched Iwander's youtube video reference and was going to post exactly what TK did before I read his. Agree 100%. The broadhead was a three blade Thunderhead, not one recommended for hogs. And as TK said, one of the blades was ripped out of its groove. Doesn't prove sh%&#. IMHO

From: Arrowflinger
Date: 29-Feb-16




I've killed hogs with the Thunderhead. When I was shooting a compound. Never a problem. I've shot a half dozen or so with a 46 pound recurve and using the 2 bladed Magnus Stinger. A couple of those hogs were Boars in the 150 plus pound range. On all but one I got good penetration. One of the older boars had a very thick shield. I certainly didn't get a pass through but I did watch him go down. In my opinion, the average hog is 80 to 120 pounds. You will have no problem if you place your shots. And I don't agree with Razorheads shot placement. Shoot for a spot just above the elbow and he wont go far. Have fun!

From: George D. Stout Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 29-Feb-16




The guys that tell you no, probably have not done it much. PM Robert Carter who posts here. He has likely already killed more hogs than some of these guys will in their lifetime. I would listen to him first, and he has killed a bunch with 45'ish weight. I would use a good cut on contact head, but wouldn't be a bit afraid of using that bow.

From: Michael Schwister Professional Bowhunters Society - Associate Member
Date: 29-Feb-16




For Magnum hogs (Russians over 250# or ferals over 350#) I strongly recommend over 600 grains, over 175 fps, and BIG snuffers or simmons shark BHs.

For most feral swine you should be ok, keep it sharp, close, and tight behind the shoulder.





If you have already registered, please

sign in now

For new registrations

Click Here




Visit Bowsite.com A Traditional Archery Community Become a Sponsor
Stickbow.com © 2003. By using this site you agree to our Terms and Conditions and our Privacy Policy