Traditional Archery Discussions on the Leatherwall


Mystery Recurve??

Messages posted to thread:
Pdiddly 29-Sep-15
Pdiddly 29-Sep-15
Pdiddly 29-Sep-15
Pdiddly 29-Sep-15
Pdiddly 29-Sep-15
Pdiddly 29-Sep-15
Oldbowyer 29-Sep-15
matt Ewing 29-Sep-15
bowhunt 29-Sep-15
jaz5833 29-Sep-15
Knifeguy 29-Sep-15
Frisky 29-Sep-15
matt Ewing 29-Sep-15
Pdiddly 29-Sep-15
Pdiddly 29-Sep-15
Pdiddly 29-Sep-15
Maytagman66 29-Sep-15
jaz5833 29-Sep-15
George D. Stout 29-Sep-15
Hal9000 29-Sep-15
George D. Stout 29-Sep-15
crookedstix 29-Sep-15
Pdiddly 29-Sep-15
Pdiddly 29-Sep-15
crookedstix 29-Sep-15
jaz5833 29-Sep-15
jaz5833 29-Sep-15
jaz5833 29-Sep-15
jaz5833 29-Sep-15
jaz5833 29-Sep-15
Pdiddly 29-Sep-15
chamookman 30-Sep-15
Will tell 30-Sep-15
Bill C 30-Sep-15
Linecutter 30-Sep-15
Nemah 30-Sep-15
mangonboat 30-Sep-15
SB 30-Sep-15
Pdiddly 30-Sep-15
Pdiddly 30-Sep-15
From: Pdiddly
Date: 29-Sep-15

Pdiddly's embedded Photo



Picked this up and not sure what I have.

I can normally identify most bows but this has got me stumped. Looks like it could have been a kit bow with the square riser...finish is well done and glass is very nice.

Could it be a Smithwick's?

Tip overlays are zebra wood and nicely laid up and filed

67" nock to nock along the belly.

No decals or markings on it...have not measured draw weight as I'm waiting for a string order from stilldub.

Here's the shelf and riser...

From: Pdiddly
Date: 29-Sep-15

Pdiddly's embedded Photo



Here's another angle of the shelf...

From: Pdiddly
Date: 29-Sep-15

Pdiddly's embedded Photo



Off side of the riser..

From: Pdiddly
Date: 29-Sep-15

Pdiddly's embedded Photo



Here's a picture of the tip...pretty substantial...

From: Pdiddly
Date: 29-Sep-15

Pdiddly's embedded Photo



Last pic of the limb and the hook...great workmanship on the glue up of the riser and lams...

Thanks for any suggestions....I expect Mr. Stout will be along and solve this mystery!

From: Pdiddly
Date: 29-Sep-15




Belly glass is an olive colour...bit of reflex off the riser. Two lams in the limbs.

From: Oldbowyer
Date: 29-Sep-15




Sure is an odd duck

From: matt Ewing
Date: 29-Sep-15




My goodness is that a holy grail?

From: bowhunt
Date: 29-Sep-15




Maybe an Eddings

From: jaz5833
Date: 29-Sep-15




Need a better look at those tips.

From: Knifeguy
Date: 29-Sep-15




Pdiddly- I'm thinking an early Gordon Plastics. Lance.

From: Frisky
Date: 29-Sep-15




Grail? That crappy thing?

Joe

From: matt Ewing
Date: 29-Sep-15




Lol

From: Pdiddly
Date: 29-Sep-15

Pdiddly's embedded Photo



I'd trade it to the Mighty Legend of the North even up for the Turquoise Toothpick but I've grown attached to it. ;>) Besides, this bow told me it wants to actually be used and not displayed like the

Tips have a three layer overlay. Two layers of zebra wood with another layer of a lighter wood between. They were symmetrical so you see the centre layer equally revealed on both ends...nice work. Grooves are well cut and exact.

From: Pdiddly
Date: 29-Sep-15

Pdiddly's embedded Photo



Here's another view from the side...quite substantial.

From: Pdiddly
Date: 29-Sep-15

Pdiddly's embedded Photo



The limbs are very nicely tapered...that's a Canuck quarter for scale.

From: Maytagman66
Date: 29-Sep-15




Might be a Root..

From: jaz5833
Date: 29-Sep-15




I'd bet $100 bucks it's a Wilson White bow from San Diego.

From: George D. Stout Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 29-Sep-15




I was thinking more like a Corky Johnson bow from California. But then, those west coast bows are not in my expertise vault.

From: Hal9000
Date: 29-Sep-15




Smithwick (sp?) or Joe Fries?

From: George D. Stout Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 29-Sep-15




The Smithwick Citation was made by Tom Jennings, the company was Smithwick-Jennings. Did Joe make his own bows? I always though he had bows made for him.

From: crookedstix
Date: 29-Sep-15




The two Joe Fries bows that I've seen each had his signature on them...Peter, do you think this is the original finish on the bow? Maybe someone has sanded away the vital information...

From: Pdiddly
Date: 29-Sep-15




The riser has definitely been refinished and likely the limbs were too. The riser has a few "fish eye" bubbles so know that it was redone. The glass is in very good shape...

There is not a stamp or mark on the bow anywhere...looked carefully.

Roots were stamped...had different riser layup and tips. Also almost alI of them had tip wedges. I have various 50's style Roots so not that.

I have an older Eddings made Whiffen Shooting Star and this is quite different.

I am convinced it is California in origin from the riser layup, limb diameter and recurve design and tips.

I have a Dana (Joe Fries), a Drake, a Dick Green and a few Gordon Plastics and this does not look like any of those.

I think jaz5383 may be onto something with the Wilson White...I have a very old White Special that I picked up from crookedstix. While this bow does not resemble it a lot as this is newer the design would fit.

Still a mystery...

From: Pdiddly
Date: 29-Sep-15




Corky Johnson is an interesting theory...

From: crookedstix
Date: 29-Sep-15




Although the early White bows (when he was with Eicholtz) had two lams in the limbs, I think his later work (on his own and with FASCO) was more likely to have extra laminations. The glass looks to be uni-directional...hmmm, this is a good mystery. I would agree, though, that those aggressively-angled short tip wedges are quite like White's bows.

From: jaz5833
Date: 29-Sep-15

jaz5833's embedded Photo



The best clue is the tips. White's were very distinctive.

From: jaz5833
Date: 29-Sep-15

jaz5833's embedded Photo



From: jaz5833
Date: 29-Sep-15

jaz5833's embedded Photo



Here's a Corky.

From: jaz5833
Date: 29-Sep-15

jaz5833's embedded Photo



That one above in a White

Here's a Corky

From: jaz5833
Date: 29-Sep-15

jaz5833's embedded Photo



Here's a Corky

From: Pdiddly
Date: 29-Sep-15




Unidirectional glass on this bow...does have a bit of deflex off the riser like the Corky.

My White has tips like those in the picture...one piece of wood.

From: chamookman
Date: 30-Sep-15




Stottler Maybe ???????? Bob

From: Will tell
Date: 30-Sep-15




Looks like a Eddings to me too.

From: Bill C
Date: 30-Sep-15




I was a kid when Joe fries was around. He did a bow build in one of those old publications and it looked just like that. I'll put my money on a Smithwick.

From: Linecutter
Date: 30-Sep-15




Looks like a Gordan Glass that buddy of mine use to have. DANNY

From: Nemah
Date: 30-Sep-15




Corky Johnson is/was my cousin! I always heard my aunt Ann brag about him and the great bows he made, but he lived in California and I live in Washington State, so we never met. I sure wish I had payed more attention, but I was young and stupid then. Now I'm older.......

From: mangonboat
Date: 30-Sep-15




It has the looks of a southern California bow.

From: SB
Date: 30-Sep-15




I'm having a hard time determining if what I am looking at is left or right handed!

From: Pdiddly
Date: 30-Sep-15

Pdiddly's embedded Photo



Right handed...green glass you can see is on the back...in the second picture at the top the belly side of the riser is facing me and is at the bottom.

I took a quick picture of the Cali bows (and an Eddings) in my collection to see what the risers look like in each of the models folks mentioned.

Left to right is a Dana (Joe Fries) with curly maple riser, a Gordon with a Gordon Plastics King peeking out, a Drake Firedrake, a very old Wilson Special, a Whiffen Shooting Star made by Eddings (not from Cali) a Na-Po with the small side plate and a Dick Green with a maple riser. The San Diego bows had lots of vertical lams in the riser and fairly straight yet narrow limbs with pronounced hooks and small tips.

The mystery bow looks similar but not exact, especially the tips. I suspect it's a Smithwick. Joe Fries and Dick Green apparently had a connection.

From: Pdiddly
Date: 30-Sep-15

Pdiddly's embedded Photo



Here are Root's from my collection...it's my understanding that Ernie Root used tip wedges at the same time as Harry Drake through exchange of ideas.

These 50's Roots had a resemblance to SoCal Bows...there were never as many lams in the riser as the western bows though. Tips were very similar and there were, as I said, tip wedges in most.

Left to right is a 64" Gamemaster with overdraw, a 66" Fieldmaster, an unmarked 64" Gamemaster that I just picked up for a song (the bump below the grip is a Pearson Palomino peeking out) and a 64" Ranger.

I don't think the mystery bow is a Root.





If you have already registered, please

sign in now

For new registrations

Click Here




Visit Bowsite.com A Traditional Archery Community Become a Sponsor
Stickbow.com © 2003. By using this site you agree to our Terms and Conditions and our Privacy Policy