Traditional Archery Discussions on the Leatherwall


Best hunting knife

Messages posted to thread:
Mighty Matt 09-Sep-14
Selden Slider 09-Sep-14
CJE 09-Sep-14
Bushbow 09-Sep-14
GF 09-Sep-14
greyghost 09-Sep-14
Frisky 09-Sep-14
HillbillyKing 09-Sep-14
KyPhil 09-Sep-14
paul craig 09-Sep-14
GF 09-Sep-14
Tomarctus 09-Sep-14
eagle_eye 09-Sep-14
Smithhammer 09-Sep-14
Selden Slider 09-Sep-14
Brookenarrow 09-Sep-14
Brookenarrow 09-Sep-14
Andy Man 09-Sep-14
BenM 09-Sep-14
doug 09-Sep-14
Andy Man 09-Sep-14
killinstuff 09-Sep-14
Chief RID 09-Sep-14
Biathlonman 09-Sep-14
longbow4life 09-Sep-14
SB 09-Sep-14
simplelife 09-Sep-14
PaPa Doc 09-Sep-14
Stumpkiller 09-Sep-14
Skeets 09-Sep-14
Mojostick 09-Sep-14
cut it out 09-Sep-14
hayestrx250r 09-Sep-14
Andy Man 09-Sep-14
JE 09-Sep-14
cut it out 09-Sep-14
hayestrx250r 09-Sep-14
crazymoose 10-Sep-14
N. Y. Yankee 10-Sep-14
stagetek 10-Sep-14
South Farm 10-Sep-14
JE 10-Sep-14
Gifford 10-Sep-14
Ron Laclairdk 11-Sep-14
EricPootatuckArchers 11-Sep-14
JLBSparks 11-Sep-14
Hal9000 11-Sep-14
camodave 11-Sep-14
JustSomeDude 11-Sep-14
r.grider 16-Sep-14
Chief RID 17-Sep-14
MGF 17-Sep-14
Jim 17-Sep-14
Steve 17-Sep-14
cyrille 17-Sep-14
reddogge 17-Sep-14
MGF 17-Sep-14
MGF 17-Sep-14
Andy Man 17-Sep-14
BOWDAWG 17-Sep-14
Copperhead 17-Sep-14
Copperhead 17-Sep-14
Easykeeper 17-Sep-14
fishinguide 17-Sep-14
Mighty Matt 17-Sep-14
Mighty Matt 17-Sep-14
Mighty Matt 17-Sep-14
From: Mighty Matt
Date: 09-Sep-14




Just received my new skinner a couple days ago. Matches my "Big 7" hunting knife. Camel bone with black liners, Nickel pins and guard with D-2 tool steel, Courtesy of Mr Stephen Lynn. I will post pics of both together soon. Lets see some pics of your favorites. Here is his site if you would like to check out some of his models. www.slynnknives.com

From: Selden Slider
Date: 09-Sep-14

Selden Slider's embedded Photo



This is my current favorite made by bodork. Frank

From: CJE
Date: 09-Sep-14

CJE's embedded Photo



Knife I made last spring for Turkey season. Probably my favorite knife so far and will be the one I carry for deer season.

From: Bushbow
Date: 09-Sep-14

Bushbow's embedded Photo



A couple I made for my bear guides. I like simple and full tang personally but all designs have their merits and I love seeing everyone's go to knives.

From: GF
Date: 09-Sep-14

GF's embedded Photo



I’ve got a new (to me) knife that I picked up as a Find, and I don’t know if I should Go-To it or not….

It’s a Lillehammer Olympics commemorative… Not sure if it was a limited edition or not, but it was evidently an important knife in the history of the company that made it.

Seems ridiculous to just leave it in the box. Not sure if I should try to sell it to a collector, trade it off, or just let it become the Go-To knife I’ve never had… I’m as much Norwegian as anything else, so it feels like it oughtta have some mojo to it Just Because…

Any ideas out there?

From: greyghost
Date: 09-Sep-14




They are much prettier than my Havalon.

From: Frisky
Date: 09-Sep-14

Frisky's embedded Photo



I take two. The Buck Vanguard and the Victorinox Hunter XT. I really don't need to use the gutting blade on the XT, but I bring it along anyway.

Joe

From: HillbillyKing Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 09-Sep-14

HillbillyKing's embedded Photo



Best from Left to right 1. Bodork 2. D2 Custom 3. Knife set from Vintage Works this i carry other 2 always in a small pack !!!

From: KyPhil
Date: 09-Sep-14

KyPhil's embedded Photo



Here's a few I have

From: paul craig
Date: 09-Sep-14




GF, that's a Helle, made in Norway, if I'm correct. Have a look at ragweedforge.com. I know nothing of collector values, but in my experience, they're very decent knives.

From: GF
Date: 09-Sep-14




Actually, a Brusletto... Upgraded version/predecessor of the Bruslettokniven. Brusletto sells the current version for around $80, so it's basically a better knife than I'd ever buy for myself... unless it's worth more because of the Lillehammer logo on it...

From: Tomarctus
Date: 09-Sep-14

Tomarctus's embedded Photo



I got this mora when I was twelve. It's gone through a pile of critters since.

From: eagle_eye
Date: 09-Sep-14

eagle_eye's embedded Photo



My new favorite. A copy of the Schrade Sharpfinger but longer. Knife is 8" with a heavy 3.75" D2 tool steel blade.

From: Smithhammer
Date: 09-Sep-14

Smithhammer's embedded Photo



I'm always a sucker for a good Loveless-style drop point.

From: Selden Slider
Date: 09-Sep-14




GF, use it. A knife like that shouldn't be left in a box. My opinion of course. Frank

From: Brookenarrow
Date: 09-Sep-14




9_164252_621.jpg" border="0" alt=" photo IMG_20140909_164252_621.jpg"/ >
From: Brookenarrow
Date: 09-Sep-14




Not sure how to post pic with a droid

From: Andy Man
Date: 09-Sep-14




Gorman " canadian belt knife" (by far the handiest I have ever used)

From: BenM
Date: 09-Sep-14




Mora

From: doug
Date: 09-Sep-14




the Buck folding hunter for the last 47yrs.

From: Andy Man
Date: 09-Sep-14

Andy Man's embedded Photo



the Canadian Belt knife

From: killinstuff
Date: 09-Sep-14

killinstuff's embedded Photo



I like big and here is 10" of hand forged blade with a mammoths tooth on the north end. All medal parts are hand made and the ivory is checkered. The clip is as sharp as the blade and sheaf adds to the knife art by Darcy Ellis of BC.

From: Chief RID
Date: 09-Sep-14

Chief RID's embedded Photo



These have done most of the knife chores for years. The Buck Red insert Protege has skinned and dressed a lot of deer. It is an inexpensive knife that sharpens easy for stainless and keeps an edge. It fits in the hand nice. The other two get forced into duty when sharpening touch up is not practical.

From: Biathlonman
Date: 09-Sep-14

Biathlonman's embedded Photo



Light my fire "Fireknife". Best $25 I've ever spent!

From: longbow4life
Date: 09-Sep-14

longbow4life's embedded Photo



My dragon hunting knife. Lol

From: SB
Date: 09-Sep-14




All I carry is my old LB-7 Schrade lock back . Never owned a fancy custom knife!

From: simplelife
Date: 09-Sep-14

simplelife's embedded Photo



I've carried these two more than a few miles. If I can't get it done with these and maybe my pack axe it ain't worth doin.

From: PaPa Doc
Date: 09-Sep-14




A sharp one!

From: Stumpkiller
Date: 09-Sep-14




Not the best camp knife. Not much to look at. But inside a deer this little Izula II is perfect for field dressing a whitetail.

 photo DSCN1142_zps2a6bb7c2.jpg

I wear this as a neck knife and then have a belt knife like my Benchmade Activator.  photo HPIM2424.jpg D2 steel - takes a mediocre edge and holds it forever. But if you take the time with a diamond hone it does hold a great edge for a long time.

Or this old Brusletto laminated blade I set in a stag handle. This one has been around the block. This one cost me about $25 in components in the early 80's and is one I keep coming back to. I pat myself on the back as I have never been able to make as good a sheath ever again (this is pigskin).  photo IM000658.jpg

From: Skeets
Date: 09-Sep-14




That Canadian Belt knife Andy Man has pictured is the most easy to handle and functional knife I have ever used. Excellent for field dressing deer. It lays in your hand right side up and upside down. I have (2) G.L.Herter knives shaped just like that. I have been using one of them since 1972 (the other was my Dad's). Skeet

From: Mojostick
Date: 09-Sep-14




A 1970's-1980's, German made, Puma 4 Star is by far the best I've found. After 100's of gutting jobs, I've never found a finer "hunting" knife. Albeit, people typically don't need a "hunting" knife, because what they really need and want is a gutting knife. For that reason, most people buy a knife that is too long with too pointed of a tip, for the typical gutting job. The "old" German Puma 4 Star's from the 1970's and 1980's are the best gutting knives ever made. For this reason, they still demand $200 plus, despite being upwards of 40 years old.

From: cut it out
Date: 09-Sep-14

cut it out's embedded Photo



Usually one of these

From: hayestrx250r
Date: 09-Sep-14

hayestrx250r's embedded Photo



This is about half of my knives in total. I am a sucker for stag handles. I want a stag handled Buck Vanguard 692 so bad it hurts. I am not big on Silver Stag knives (although the dagger pictured is one) but I wouldn't mind a Silver Stag Boar Sword. A couple to point out here are: 1)Buck quickfire bottom left my favorite EDC it is cheap enough not to sweat using or loosing. 2)Schrade Squire IV small stag lock blade bottom center,it was the first knife gifted to me by my parents for the first straight A's report card when I was about 6 or 7years old. 3)Buck 110 top right worn out, my father's knife my mother bought him the at the same shop the same day as my Schrade back in the 80's.

From: Andy Man
Date: 09-Sep-14




Skeets; mine was a hand me down from my mother She used it all of the time ,always thought kinda odd looking

When she passed I decided to use it; Suprise; The best darn knife I ever used

gets ultra sharp, stays sharp and just handles so nicely, one would have to try it to know how much better it is over anything else. I have a high dollar puma and Randall, and as far as utility they don't match it

From: JE
Date: 09-Sep-14

JE's embedded Photo



I've been packing this one around for a couple months now and really like it. Cable Damascus with red wood and wenge scales.

From: cut it out
Date: 09-Sep-14

cut it out's embedded Photo



I do carry a bigger camp knife when bear hunting the Big woods also. Usually this Randall model 14

From: hayestrx250r
Date: 09-Sep-14

hayestrx250r's embedded Photo



Forgot a skinner made by a local

From: crazymoose
Date: 10-Sep-14




I carry a Russell Belt knife and a Swiss Army Hunter.

From: N. Y. Yankee
Date: 10-Sep-14




I carry a larger fixed-blade for heavy work and a folder with a finer edge for more precise cutting.

From: stagetek Professional Bowhunters Society - Qualified Member
Date: 10-Sep-14




I have a fixed blade Buck knife given to me in the early 70's. It's been with me on every hunt I've been on.

From: South Farm
Date: 10-Sep-14




Proud to say I'm still using the fixed blade Western bone handle Mom and Dad got me for Christmas a 35 years ago! In a moment of weakness back in the 90's I bought a Benchmade with a saw blade thinking it would be "better", but that got relegated to a junk drawer and me and the Western are still hunting buddies. I think I'd be lost and give up hunting without it..

From: JE
Date: 10-Sep-14




Those old Westerns are good knives.

From: Gifford
Date: 10-Sep-14




I generally carry my Swiss army knife and a Buck Skinner (so I'm an optimist). The Buck General and Pathfinder are in my pack. I think the newest of these was acquired about 1970. Sure I've got others but these seem to always go along with me.

From: Ron Laclairdk Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 11-Sep-14

Ron Laclairdk's embedded Photo



From: EricPootatuckArchers
Date: 11-Sep-14




Buck folding hunter (110) since 1970's

From: JLBSparks
Date: 11-Sep-14




+1 with Eric. I have one so old that it doesn't say "110", and "Buck" is readable with the blade pointed down.

-Joe

From: Hal9000
Date: 11-Sep-14




Got one at Menards for $3 and have been using it for years. The Blade is Honzo Steel and the handle is made from the jaw bone of a 27 point super buck.... 2 more payments and it will be all mine :)

From: camodave
Date: 11-Sep-14




After watching a friend who shoots maybe a hundred caribou a year take five apart with a cheap fish knife I am convinced that it is not the instrument it is the musician...the more I shoot different equipment the more I believe that when it come to bows too...I have lots of knives but I am fully aware I could get by with a couple or even one...come to think of it my guide friends can skin just about anything with a 6 dollar paring knife, and they complain the blades are a bit too long

DDave

From: JustSomeDude
Date: 11-Sep-14




I have a similar Bodork that a few others have posted here. I like it so much that I really don't knife shop any more.

From: r.grider
Date: 16-Sep-14




hayestrx250r , thats a Bimbo Knife aint it ? Sheep hoirn handle i believe ? saw his at KyTradFest, have bought two of his knives already, Love 'em !

From: Chief RID
Date: 17-Sep-14




Sure are some pretty and useful knives in this thread. Thanks for all the great pics. Now. I sure would like to use anything on a deer today.

From: MGF
Date: 17-Sep-14




"After watching a friend who shoots maybe a hundred caribou a year take five apart with a cheap fish knife I am convinced that it is not the instrument it is the musician...the more I shoot different equipment the more I believe that when it come to bows too...I have lots of knives but I am fully aware I could get by with a couple or even one...come to think of it my guide friends can skin just about anything with a 6 dollar paring knife, and they complain the blades are a bit too long DDave "

My wife and I raise some meat animals so we do a fair amount butchering. Most of it is done with cheap kitchen knives.

I like a nice knife as much as anybody and I even make knives. But, I think the most important things are knowing how to sharpen a knife and how to use one.

From: Jim Compton's Traditional Bowhunters
Date: 17-Sep-14




I love my good old S.K. Olsen. I have used it exclusively since 1970 and never had a problem with it. It sharpens easy and hold an edge. Jim :)

From: Steve
Date: 17-Sep-14




From looking at the pictures there appears to be plenty of stainless and plenty of carbon knives. I've been in the market for a new fixed blade and the Canadian Belt knife caught my attention. You can purchase stainless or carbon; what do folks prefer?

From: cyrille
Date: 17-Sep-14




The BEST hunting knife... is the one that YOU decide is best for you!

From: reddogge Professional Bowhunters Society - Qualified Member
Date: 17-Sep-14




I carry one of these 60s Pumas bowhunting each year.

Pumas right photo IMG_0518.jpg

I carry this titanium Buck folder rifle hunting in the salt marshes of MD (top of picture).

Buck knives photo Buckknives.jpg

From: MGF
Date: 17-Sep-14




There are hard plain carbon steel blades and soft...same with stainless.

Hardness of a finished blade is primarily a function of the heat treating that has been applied...provides the alloy has enough carbon in it to be hardened.

A plain high carbon steel blade immediately after quench (hardening) is so hard that it can shatter like glass. Tempering is the process that softens it enough to be useful (not shatter). During tempering, the hardness can be drawn back as much or as little as desired depending on the blades intended use.

Point is that stainless blades aren't always "harder" to sharpen and they don't necessarily hold an edge better.

Many commercial blades (including stainless) feel and bend like they're pretty soft.

I suspect that they do this for ease of machining, though there are other reasons to make/use a soft blade. Final dimensioning (grinding) is usually done after heat treating to avoid warping and decarburization. Really hard blades eat up grinding belts and take longer to grind...i.e., they'll cost more to make.

Makers of quality blades sometimes will state the hardness of the blade on the Rockwell scale. I say sometimes because there are plenty of good bladesmiths who do their own heat treating and may not test their blade in that way.

From: MGF
Date: 17-Sep-14




Carbon steel blades (non-stainless) are making something of a come back...did they ever really get unpopular?

The bushcraft and "survival" crowds like them because you can throw sparks off them with a piece of flint or quartz...you can use them to make a fire.

I make my own knives and I use non-stainless high carbon steels because I know how to work with them. I've tested them and they throw fine sparks, however, I have ferro rods, flint strikers, Bick lighters, matches and I can even use a bow drill so I don't normally beat on my blades with rocks. LOL

From: Andy Man
Date: 17-Sep-14




I have the stainless in the canadian belt knife- sharpens fine and holds an edge great

Beat skinning knofe I have, by a mile

From: BOWDAWG
Date: 17-Sep-14




Mora clipper heavy duty

From: Copperhead
Date: 17-Sep-14

Copperhead's embedded Photo



Depends upon what I am 'hunting'........

From: Copperhead
Date: 17-Sep-14

Copperhead's embedded Photo



This is a bit more practical............

From: Easykeeper
Date: 17-Sep-14




I use a Buck 110, go through one every couple of years. I don't wear them out I loose them working around the place...lol. It's a good knife and cheap enough I don't get upset when they go missing.

I've always wanted a Randall...just because I've always wanted one. Probably get one someday but it will be reserved for hunting only, no fencing or general chores.

From: fishinguide
Date: 17-Sep-14

fishinguide's embedded Photo



My current favorites.

From: Mighty Matt
Date: 17-Sep-14

Mighty Matt's embedded Photo



I cant figure how to post from my camera but this is the Big 7. Mine has the bone handle,D2 steel but has nickel guard and pins instead of brass.

From: Mighty Matt
Date: 17-Sep-14




Here is the skinner I also have but with bone,nickel combo to match the big 7. It also has a shorter guard as suggested By Mr. Lynn for a knife that will actually be used rather than displayed. I have been a Knife nut for a long time and Stephen Lynn has more than impressed me with the quality of the knives I have gotten from him. I might be looking into having him make me one of those Canadian belt knives soon also.

From: Mighty Matt
Date: 17-Sep-14

Mighty Matt's embedded Photo







If you have already registered, please

sign in now

For new registrations

Click Here




Visit Bowsite.com A Traditional Archery Community Become a Sponsor
Stickbow.com © 2003. By using this site you agree to our Terms and Conditions and our Privacy Policy